/ratanon/ - Rationalists Anonymous

Remember when /ratanon/ was good?

Posting mode: Reply

Check to confirm you're not a robot
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
Password
Drawing x size canvas
File(s)

Board Rules

Max file size: 350.00 MB

Max files: 5

Max message length: 4096

Manage Board | Moderate Thread

Return | Magrathea | Catalog | Bottom

Expand All Images


(109.97 KB 611x578 great filter.png)
The Great Filter Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 03:48:06 [Preview] No. 5042
Does pic related solve the Great Filter problem?


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 03:48:23 [Preview] No.5043 del
Space is extremely empty, and there are natural signals to compare to.
I haven't done the math, but the chance that people involved with SETI haven't is nil.


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 03:48:39 [Preview] No.5044 del
No. On cosmological timescales the time between a technological civilization arising and them conquering the galaxy is essentially an instant. Detection through broadcast is just a red herring. The existence of isolated technological civilizations just happening to come into being at the same time as us is extremely improbable.


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 03:49:12 [Preview] No.5046 del
>>5044
this
Exponential growth is one hell of a drug.


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 04:25:42 [Preview] No.5151 del
There is some discussion at https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/17765/from-how-far-away-could-our-seti-searches-detect-and-recognize-our-technological .

Apparently, we do not yet have big enough radio telescopes to detect "leaking" Earth-like radio signals from another planet, so SETI hoped to discover an intensional signal. For example, many early SETI efforts searched for a radio signal around the "water hole" frequency, hoping that would be a Schelling point for trying to communicate with aliens.

But the great filter problem is not just about Earth-like civilizations. Fermi thought that technological civilizations should quickly become big enough to settle entire galaxies, so then the "great filter" is whatever prevents that—just inverse-square radio signals is not an explanation for that.



Top | Catalog | Post a reply | Magrathea | Return