/ratanon/ - Rationalists Anonymous

Remember when /ratanon/ was good?

Posting mode: Reply

Check to confirm you're not a robot
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
Password
Drawing x size canvas
File(s)

Board Rules

Max file size: 350.00 MB

Max files: 5

Max message length: 4096

Manage Board | Moderate Thread

Return | Magrathea | Catalog | Bottom

Expand All Images


(230.68 KB 1250x1900 cover.jpg)
Elephant in the Brain Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 08:29:54 [Preview] No. 5755
Did y'all read this book? What did you think? I already bought the thesis before opening it, but it was fun seeing all the specific behaviors explored.

It feels like a slight information hazard though. Not sure if I should recommend it to normies.


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 10:22:47 [Preview] No.6112 del
>>5755
Does he say all human behaviour is signaling or anything like that? I've noticed a lot of fans implying it but that seems nonsensical.


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 10:23:19 [Preview] No.6114 del
>>6112
The core thesis is that everything we do is ultimately selfish or genetically selfish, or a currently maladaptive execution of a selfish adaptation - you get the idea, even though it's not in our interest to be consciously aware of it. That's the elephant in the room/brain, something that's really obvious but rarely discussed.
That means a huge chunk of human behavior is signaling, including a lot of less obvious things. Like voting, for example - the miniscule probability of changing the outcome isn't selfishly worth the time investment, but it's an excellent opportunity to signal that you're smart/knowledgeable/loyal. It even claims much of healthcare is signaling.
Not absolutely everything is signaling, but there's a lot more of it than you'd think.


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 10:24:44 [Preview] No.6118 del
>>6112
> Does he say all human behaviour is signaling or anything like that?

Not as much in the book than in his blog.

> I've noticed a lot of fans implying it but that seems nonsensical.

It is.


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 10:28:25 [Preview] No.6131 del
I honestly found this book echoing thoughts I already have. I have a big deterministic hardon. I have yet to find a counter argument.


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 10:30:37 [Preview] No.6139 del
>>6131
>deterministic hardon
this sounds like something out of rationalist doujinshi.


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 10:33:45 [Preview] No.6148 del
>>6139

> “Please, onii-san. I want to you to be my first. I want to feel you inside me before anyone else.”

> “But you're my little sister,” I said. “We can't… *I* can't do it, it's *wrong*.”

> “And yet you can’t *not* do it, can you? Ultimately, humans are just state machines. Every stimulus”—here she looked me in the eye and started to lazily shrug off her pink pajamas top, exposing a nipple—“triggers a chain reactions of chemicals and firing neurons, which eventually lead to a response.” She glanced downwards and smiled knowingly.

> “Onii-san, whatever will happen in this room was was determined by the laws of nature. There is no ‘ought’ without a ‘can’. You don’t have any moral responsibility, because you never had a choice.”


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 10:34:01 [Preview] No.6149 del
>>6148
except the whole point of the book is that were are not practicing incest for example because of the pregnancy risk, practical birth control is only something recent


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 10:34:34 [Preview] No.6151 del
>>6131

are you hard enough for superdeterminism?


Anonymous 08/13/2019 (Tue) 11:01:49 [Preview] No.6238 del
(20.61 KB 622x120 goodreads review.png)



Top | Catalog | Post a reply | Magrathea | Return